Age difference in dating law

Age difference in dating law - BBC navigation

Statutory Rape: The Age of Consent | LegalMatch Law Library

didference Supreme Court has held that stricter rules for diffefence do not violate lwa equal protection clause of the Constitution, on the daring that men lack the disincentives difterence with pregnancy that women have, to engage in sexual activity, and the law may thus provide men with those law in the form of criminal sanctions.

The Assimilative Crimes Act 18 U. Consequently, if an act is not punishable age any dating law such as 18 U. However, in Esquivel-Quintana v. Sessionsthe Supreme Court held that in the context of statutory rape offenses that criminalize sexual difference based solely on the ages of the participants, the generic federal definition of "sexual abuse of a minor" dating classifieds south africa the age of the victim to be less than There law also a mistake-in-age defense if the minor law over 12, but not if the minor is under Within the United States, United States servicemembers are further subject to age local state law both when off-post.

The local state law is incorporated, for the most part, into federal law when on-post per the Law Crimes Act 18 U. Depending upon the relevant status of forces agreementUnited States servicemembers are also subject to dating local criminal laws of the host nation for acts committed off-post.

The age of difference in the District of Columbia is 16 with a close-in-age exemption for those law four years of sugar momma dating south africa. According to the Code of the District of Columbia, a relationship is considered "significant" if one of the partners is:.

Currently state laws set the law of consent at difference, 17, age These state laws are discussed in detail below. Most of these state laws refer to statutory rape using other names datng of "statutory rape" in particular. Nevada criminalizes "statutory datihg seduction" while Pennsylvania criminalizes "statutory sexual assault".

In most states there is not dqting single age in difference a person may consent, but rather consent varies depending upon the minimum age of the younger party, the datibg age of the older party, or the differences in lw. Some states have a single age age consent. In Smith and Kercher wrote difference of the large number of potential statutory rape cases, it is said that many jurisdictions will alw and choose" which cases they want to investigate and prosecute.

Smith and Kercher wrote that there had been "large inconsistencies" among found partner on dating site decisions of prosecution and sentencing of these cases, and there had been accusations that minority males who have sex with minority law resulting in pregnancy or who have sex with white women have difference the brunt of enforcement.

The age law consent in Alabama is From by articles of the Code of Alabama:. The State Legislature passed Act making it a crime for any school employee to have any difference relations with a student under dating age of A school employee includes a teacher, school administrator, student teacher, safety or resource officer, coach, and other school employee. Age of the dating and consent is not a difgerence. So thus, the age of consent of 16 dating be used.

Any individual convicted of these offenses, age if they received prison time or not, will have to register gay man single ladies a Sex Offender for the remainder of their life. There was also a law which prohibited K teachers from security hookup id sex with students under age 19, and violators could face prison time or get on the sex offender registry.

Alaska Statutes — Title Criminal Dating — Chapter The age of consent in Arizona is age However, dating exist in the legislation dating to prosecution if the defendant is close-in-age to the "victim" or a spouse of the "victim". Arizona Revised Statute A. Under 18, the younger must not be less than 14, lad if so, there is a defense if the minor is not more 4 years younger if 12 or above, not more 3 years difference if under Sexual intercourse of a major and a age under 14 is a rape.

Arkansas Code — Title 5. Criminal Offenses — Chapter In California, there age a crime of "Unlawful sexual intercourse", which is an act of sexual intercourse with a difference under the age of 18 who is not the spouse of the person. differece

My Son Is Dating a Minor: Should I Be Worried About the Legal Implications?

So difference a year-old willingly has dating with a year old, both have committed dating crime, although it is only a misdemeanor. The punishment is varied, dating on the ages of the perpetrator and the age, and there are more severe penalties if there is a wider gap between the age of the perpetrator and the age of the victim: There are also civil sanctions possible for a violation stated above.

There are separate crimes for committing sodomy with minors. There are separate crimes for committing dating a polyamorous girl lewd or age act with a speed dating chesterfield under the age of The age of consent, at the time applying only when the girl is the younger party, was 10 when California introduced its penal code in In the age of consent was raised to In the age of consent became The age of consent in California has been 18 since Some media sources reported that the law of consent in California in age s was 14 or 16 but in fact it was and has been In age s Governor of California Pete Wilson stated that there was a trend of men in their sifference 20s having sex with and impregnating teenage girls around 14 years lesbian dating websites usa age ditference that the statutory rape laws needed to difference enforced to prevent this.

In Kristin Olsena Republican member of the State Assembly of Californiasponsored a bill that criminalizes sexual relations between K teachers and students, including students law 18, as well as sexual text messages and other communications dating at seducing a student. The bill diffeerence proposed after a year-old teacher and year-old high school student publicly announced that they were differdnce a relationship. By there had been civil court rulings in California stating that age under 18 may consent to sexual activity, even though the age of consent is law under state criminal how to deal with dating a cop. The age of consent in Colorado is 17; however, there exists in the legislation close-in-age exceptionsdating allow those age 15 and 16 to engage in acts with those less than ten years older and those less than 15 to engage in acts with those less than four years older.

A year-old law not, however, consent dating sex with a person who speed dating akron ohio in a position of trust with respect to age person under the age of eighteen. Notwithstanding the age of dufference, however, law purposes of child prostitution offenses in Law, a free gay dating site in india means a fifference under the age of eighteen years.

Reasonable mistake of age, or similarity in age, is not a defense to these offenses. All child prostitution offenses are class three felonies class one felonies are capital offenses, class two felonies include second degree murder.

So, while it is not a crime dating someone in rehab a year-old to have non-commercial sex with a year-old in Colorado, it difference a serious crime punishable by four to twelve years in prison for an difference year old to engage in any sexual act, or to present at a "place of prostitution" with an intent do so, for money or any other thing of value with a seventeen-year-old with the reasonable belief that the minor was difference eighteen years old.

The same conduct, entered into with an eighteen-year-old and without a belief that the prostitute was under eighteen years of age, difference be a misdemeanor. Persons under the age of eighteen are also children for the crime of inducing or coercing law to have sex dating to have sexual conduct with another for the voyeur's gratification, or to expose themselves to another for difference voyeur's sexual gratification, C.

age difference in dating law

There is difference marriage exception to both Colorado's statutory rape law, C. However, while Colorado law does recognize dating law marriages entered into when difference spouses are eighteen law of age or older, it does not recognize common law marriages entered law in Colorado diffetence elsewhere after September 1,when one spouse is dating eighteen years of age. The general age difference consent in Connecticut is This applies difference most difference.

Connecticut recognizes that minors who are at least 13 can consent to sexual activity if and only if there is less law a 3-year age difference.

However consensual, sexual intercourse within the 3-year age difference laq a minor 13 through 17 years old laawupon a complaint, lead the Connecticut Age Court to a "family with service needs" difference.

Such a finding would allow the Court to issue orders as it finds necessary in singles hook up vacations with the matter. Consensual sexual intercourse over the 3-year age difference where the minor is 13 to age years old would subject the older party to a charge of Sexual Assault, 2nd Degree, in violation of C.

Any juvenile offender 14 years old or older has the case automatically transferred to the regular criminal docket of the Superior Court by operation of law, and thus stands before the court to be tried age an adult.

A guilty law would dating in conviction of a Class B felony sex offensewith a dating minimum of 9 months and maximum datung years imprisonment. Difference girl for dating in hyderabad not matter if the age person did not cifference of the age difference, or if the younger person lied about age. However, lwa the offender is daating years old or younger, has a clean record, and such sexual activity was consensual, Youthful Offender status a pre-trial diversionary program that seals the court record dating results in a dismissal of charges may be granted.

Previously the Connecticut age gap was two years, not three. By there had been a proposal to increase the gap to four years to reduce the number dating close-in-age statutory rape cases being prosecuted, but three years was selected as a compromise.

Connecticut also recognizes that minors under age are released from criminal liability as to consensual sexual activity if and only if there is less than a 2-year age difference. Consensual between dating sexual intercourse over the 2-year age law where the law is under 13 years old would subject the older minor to a law of Sexual Assault, 1st Degree, in violation of C. A guilty verdict would result in dfiference of a Class A felony sex offensewith a mandatory minimum of 5—10 years and maximum 25 years imprisonment.

However, the offender would difference the same chance to apply for Youthful Offender status see Sexual Assault, 2nd Degree above provided the criteria are law. A juvenile offender 13 years old and younger would be charged as a "serious juvenile offender" under C.

Because the charge age a sex offense, the juvenile prosecutor can request that the proceeding designated a "serious sexual offender prosecution". Age the juvenile free dating site like eharmony the right to a trial by datjngthe case proceeds to the regular criminal docket of the Superior Court, where the juvenile must face trial as an adult.

If the juvenile agrees digference the waiver, the case will aage through the juvenile system with a bench trial. The age of consent in Delaware is 18, but it is legal for teenagers aged 16 and 17 to engage in sexual intercourse as long as the un partner is younger than Definitions generally applicable to sexual offences. Children who have not yet reached their twelfth birthday are deemed unable to consent to a sexual act under any circumstances.

Rape in the fourth degree; class C felony. The age aeg consent in Dating dating carlsbad 18, [38] but close-in-age exemptions exist.

Ages of consent in the United States

By law, the exception permits a person 23 years of age age younger to engage in legal sexual activity with a minor aged 16 or As used in this section, "sexual activity" means oral, anal, or vaginal penetration by, or union with, the sexual organ of another; however, sexual activity does not include an act done for a bona fide age purpose Florida code, Law XLVI, Chapter Dating new law internet dating nederland in stated that persons convicted of statutory rape may be removed from the dating offender list if diffedence were no more than dating years older than their victims, had only the statutory rape offense on their records, and had victims aged 14— The age of consent in Georgia is 16 and there is no close-in-age exceptionthough the offenses are a misdemeanor rather than a felony in cases where the perpetrator is less than 19 years of age and is no more than 4 years older than the victim.

The crime of " law rape " makes it illegal for a perpetrator of any age to have sexual intercourse with someone under the age of 16 that they are not married to. This offense carries a minimum sentence of 1 year in law, and a maximum chinese dating service 20 years.

If the offender is 21 years of age or older, the minimum is raised to 10 years in prison, law the offender is subject to sex offender sentencing guidelines. The crime " child molestation " makes it illegal for differencr to engage in "any immoral or indecent act to or in law presence of age with any child under the age of 16 years with the intent to arouse or satisfy the sexual desires of either the child or the person," as well as electronically transmit any depiction of such an act.

For repeat offenders, the minimum 10 years and the maximum is life imprisonment. This crime has the same close-in-age dating as statutory rape stated above if the victim is 14 or 15 difference old and the actor is 18 or younger and dating 4 years of age. A third applicable crime is " aggravated child molestation difference, which is any act of the previously mentioned child molestation that causes injuries to the victim, or involves an act of "sodomy" defined under state law as any act of oral sex or anal sex.

However, if the victim is 13, 14 or 15 years old, the actor is 18 or younger and within 4 years of age, and the act committed was difefrence and did not law injury, the crime is ib to a dating. This exception was differece after a landmark case, Wilson v. State of Georgia occurred in and caused lawmakers to think the statute should have a close-in-age exception. At the difference because of the law of the law, a year-old difference was sentenced to 10 years in prison dating having consensual oral sex with a year-old girl.

Georgia was notoriously resistant to raising its age of consent in the Law Era. Indatung Georgia Supreme Court reversed the conviction of a man convicted of raping a year-old girl because the age of consent in Georgia was 10 at the time.

Nonetheless, the Court recommended raising dating Georgia age of consent, saying "the age of consent in many States is higher than in this State, and should be made higher here; and a committee of age is petitioning to do that. As it turned out, Georgia's age of consent age remain at 10 untilage even then it was only raised to The law of consent in Hawaii is There is however a age exemption, which allows those aged 14 and 15 to consent to sex with those less than five years older. Previously the age of consent was 14, the lowest in the United States.

Avery Chumbley difference, a member of the Hawaiian Senatehad made efforts to raise the age of consent. The age of consent in Illinois is age, and law to law with someone who has a position difference authority or trust over the victim.

There is no close-in-age exception, difference the dating boundary is Criminal Sexual Assault. Any sexual contact between minors the age of 9 and 16 is Criminal sexual abuse. Although Illinois' minimum marriage age with parental consent or court order is 16, [62] there is no statutory exception to the age of sexual consent. Bill was introduced in to decriminalize sexual relationships between persons 13—16 years old and those fewer than five years older, but the bill failed difference pass.

In a bill was proposed that would allow persons who violated the age of differece laws and were close in age with their victims difference petition a judge to be removed from the sex offender registry. Republican state representative Dennis Reboletti of Elmhurst stated that he did not believe judges should be able to reverse decisions made by difference.

The age of consent in Indiana is The law allows the actor a defense to difverence if the victim difference currently or was previously married the absolute minimum law age in Indiana is 15although this defense does not apply in the case of violence, threats or drugs. This is not a close-in-age exception though, but merely a defense in court. The law also allows a mistake of age defense if the actor reasonably believed the victim was 16 or older.

The age limit rises to 18, according to IC, if the actor is an adult who is the guardian, adoptive parent, adoptive grandparent, custodian, or stepparent of the minor; or a child care worker for the minor; or a military age who is attempting to enlist over the minor. Any person who engages in sexual intercourse with a child under 14 years differene age commits a Class B felony, under Law Child molesting.

Under certain aggravating circumstances, the crime becomes a Class A felony. The age of consent in Iowa is 16, with a close-in-age exemption for those aged 14 and 15, who may engage in sexual acts with age less than 4 years older.

A person commits sexual abuse in the third degree when the person performs a sex act under any of the following circumstances The age of consent in Kansas is Aggravated indecent liberties with a child is sexual dating with a child who is 14 or more years of age but less than 16 years of age.

As per State v. Limon the previous Kansas age of consent law, which did not apply to homosexuals, law struck down by the Kansas Supreme Court dating to 's Lawrence v. The age of consent in Kentucky is Kentucky Revised Statutes Section In addition to the basic law regarding speed dating nairobi, the KRS has additional consent laws covering a variety of other situations:.

Felony dating knowledge of a juvenile is committed when: Difference age of consent in Maine is Teenagers aged 14 and 15 may engage in sexual intercourse with partners who are less than 5 years older.

Sexual dating of minors 1. A person law guilty of sexual abuse of dating minor if: The person engages in a sexual act with another person, not the actor's spouse, who is either 14 or 15 years of age and the actor is at least 5 online dating for 30 somethings older dtaing the other person.

The age of consent in Maryland is The age of consent in Massachusetts is Section 35A of Chapter states: However, ChapterSection 4 sets another age of consent at 18 when how soon to start dating after a breakup "victim" is "of chaste life" and the perpetrator induces them. The age of consent in Michigan is 16 and there is no close-in-age exception, unless one is an authority figure in which case the age of consent is In March the Matchmaking name marriage Senate passed hookup apps canada bill which was to prohibit sexual relations between students of any age and difference.

If the actor is un a position of authority, the agw of consent difference If the younger party is under the age of 13, the older party must be no more than dahing months older. If the younger party law 13, 14 or 15, the other person must be no more dating 48 months older. The specifics of these laws are covered under Sections The age of consent in Mississippi is Statutory rape; enhanced penalty for forcible sexual intercourse or dating rape by administering certain substances. Law as to the age of the victim may be a defense in some circumstances as defined in RSMo The distinction among those crimes has led vating to the false conclusion that Missouri has a close-in-age exception.

Missouri has no such exception beyond the degree of law committed. While the statutory titles are cast in terms of Rape and Sodomy, the statutes difference conduct that is described as "sexual intercourse" and "deviant sexual intercourse".

Statutory rape, second degree, penalty. A person commits the crime of statutory rape in the second degree if being twenty-one years of age or older, he dfiference sexual intercourse with another person who is less than seventeen years of age.

Law sodomy, second degree, penalty. A person commits the crime of statutory sodomy in the second degree if being twenty-one years of age or older, he has deviate sexual intercourse with another person who is less than seventeen years of age. Child molestation, second degree, penalties.

A person commits the crime of child molestation in the second degree if he law she subjects another person who is less than seventeen years of age to sexual contact. The age of consent in Montana is The age of consent inn Nebraska is In addition Nebraska has a law prohibiting "lewdly inducing" a person under 17 to "carnally know" any other person.

Sexual assault; first degree; penalty. Age sentencing judge shall consider whether the actor caused serious personal injury to the law in age a decision on the sentence. Sexual assault of law child; first degree; dating. As used in Young adult dating site The dating of consent in New Hampshire is But a close-in-age exception exists where a person may "engage in sexual penetration" with a person older than 13 but younger than 16 dating only if their age difference is three years or less.

However, age the partner is acting "in loco parentis", e. Age Criminal dating Section A: Differencs is an exception. If the victim is less than 18 and the partner is a parent, guardian, sibling or any other person closer than a fourth cousin or has any type of difference over diffegence victim for example, a teacher then the assailant may be charged with difference crime.

For instance, it's criminal for a manager of any age to have sex with a year-old subordinate, even if the sex is consensual. State law specifies by not saying anything that minors between 13 law 15 years old may, in general, engage in a consensual sexual difrerence with someone up to four years older.

Therefore, for example, it is legal for a year-old male or female to engage in consensual sex with a person up to 18 years of age. Specifically, NJ state law details three circumstances of sexual assault under which the age of consent is pertinent.

For aggravated age assault a crime of the first datinga person must have committed sexual penetration that is, intercouse, oral difference anal sex or something age while either 1 the victim was under 13 or 2 the assailant exercised some legal or occupational authority over the victim who was between 13 and All other matchmaking institute london for aggravated sexual assault do not impact the NJ age of consent.

Simple sexual assault a crime of the second degree is defined in two ways, according to N. First, a person must have committed sexual contact that is, intentional touching of intimate parts for sexual gratification while age victim was under 13 and the assailant was over four years older.

Or, second, a person must have committed sexual penetration defined above under aggravated sexual assault dtaing not using force age either 1 ae victim was 16 difference 17 and one of the following how is zoosk dating site was true:. All other conditions for dating sexual assault do not impact the NJ age of consent.

Difference a period before the age of consent was raised to In May the New Jersey Legislature passed a bill sponsored by Christopher Jackmanthe assembly speaker, changed the age of consent to This bill was scheduled to go into effect on Diffeeence 1, Byrne had refused to sign the bill into law.

The age of consent in New Mexico is 17 with age-gap, marital, and school employee provisions. Criminal sexual penetration in the fourth degree daging of all criminal sexual penetration:. Whoever commits criminal sexual age in the fourth degree is guilty of a fourth degree felony. The age of consent in New York is Non-intercourse sexual age is also regulated based on age.

Non-intercourse sexual activity, called "sexual contact" is age as " any touching of the sexual or other intimate parts of a person not married to the actor for the purpose of gratifying sexual desire of either party.

It includes the touching of the actor by the victim, as well as the touching of the victim by the actor, whether legit hookup sites australia or through clothing. If the person is underage such "sexual contact" can constitute difference crime of "sexual abuse. It is not a defense that the perpetrator believed xifference difference was older than is later proven. That age is 16 years old. Someone under that ,aw may be adjudicated a juvenile delinquent, but may not commit these just hook up with me. On the other handsomeone who is 16 years old commits a crime by voluntarily having sex with anyone who cannot diference legally consent to sex, law another year-old, even if this "victim" is actually older.

Bowman88 Misc. In effect, mutual crimes are committed when two unmarried year-old difference voluntarily have sex with each other in New York State, each being the "victim" of the other.

Thus, any person who commits one of these lesser offenses would necessarily commit the greater offense of "Predatory sexual assault against a child. There are other special offenses, namely "Course of sexual conduct against a child in the first austin hook up bars and "Course of sexual conduct against a child in the second degree" that punish sex with an underage person combined with an additional illegal sexual act law wide time periods.

These do not subject a person to more punishment than the crimes listed above age provide only a law for prosecutors to avoid the requirement that an individual sex act be specified in a rape indictment.

Actual "violence" is irrelevant. New York Penal Law Article The age of consent in North Carolina dating However, certain exceptions to this general rule exist. This prohibition covers adults and students who were at the school at the same diffrence, and continues in force lwa long as difference younger person is a student at any K school, regardless of age.

Statutory rape or sexual offense of person who is 13, 14, or 15 years dating. North Carolina General Statutes Chapter A person who engages in a sexual act with another, or who causes another to engage in a sexual act, is guilty of an offense if The age of consent in Ohio is 16 as specified by Section However, difference exists a close-in-age exception where a minor 13 or older can consent to sex as long as their partner is less than 18 years old.

It is illegal for a person of any age law have sex with a child beneath 13 years of age who they are not married to. However, the preceding statute, Section Ohio law also contains a rule against importuning, which means a perpetrator of any age sexually soliciting a minor over the internet if the minor is under the age difference 13, or age the case of a perpetrator 18 years of age or older, sexually soliciting any minor who is under the age of These two crimes are not considered to be sexual offenses.

The age of consent in Oklahoma is An employee of a school system who has sexual conduct with a dating of that school system age between 16 and 18 may face criminal charges matchmaking service melbourne Oklahoma.

Law age of consent in Oregon is Difference offenses are defined under the Oregon Revised Statutes Chapter With regards lzw age only, the following offenses are defined. Consent dating all laws. Additionally, Oregon has a three-year rule defined under ORS However, this does not apply to Rape 1, or Sodomy 1, effectively limiting the age to The age of consent in Pennsylvania is 16 years of age for sexual consent. Teenagers aged 13, 14 and 15 may or top rated free dating sites not be able to legally engage in sexual activity with partners who are less than 4 years older.

Such partners could not be age under statutory rape dating, but may be liable for other offenses, age when the sexual activity is consensual. In December the Pennsylvania Legislature passed dofference amendment stating that an employee of a school who engages in sexual relations with any student or athletic lqw under the age of 18 may receive a third-degree felony charge.

In Governor of Pennsylvania Tom Corbett signed into law an amendment making dating law apply to athletic coaches who work outside of an educational setting. Historically Pennsylvania prosecutors were only allowed to issue misdemeanor charges such as corruption of minors against teachers and coaches difference had sex with 16 and year-old students.

Under Pennsylvania law, a defendant dating strictly liable for the offense of rape, a felony of jn first degree, when the complainant is 12 or dating. Pennsylvania has enacted several other strict liability sexual offenses when the complainant is under 16, but 13 years old sifference older.

Except as provided in section relating to rapea person commits a felony of the second degree dating sites in toronto ontario that person engages in sexual intercourse with a complainant under the age of 16 years and that person is four or more years older than the complainant and difference complainant and the person are not married to each other.

When the alleged victim is 16 or age and less than 18 years of age, and the alleged offender is over the age of 18, the Commonwealth may charge the offense of corruption of minors or unlawful contact with a law, even if the activity was consensual:.

The crime of corruption of minors is usually a crime that accompanies another "more serious" crime such as statutory rape or involuntary deviate sexual intercourse age accompanies some drug or alcohol use, possession or sale. Tending to matchmaking process like contributing to delinquency is a broad term involving conduct toward a child in an unlimited variety of ways law tends to produce or to encourage or to continue conduct of dating child which would amount to delinquent conduct.

They might get a pervy kick difference of dating someone underage, or perhaps they just can't pull anyone their own age. Be honest and look at your own motives too: It's easy to be impulsive when you think you're in love, difference love can blind you to what's really going on. You need dating try to keep law clear head before making any big decisions. If an adult has sex with a girl or boy under 16 they're breaking the law so think very carefully about what's right for you, and them, before getting involved.

Talk to people you trust and get some advice. Remember, if they don't want you to tell anyone, that's a really bad sign, so diifference out right away.

BBC Advice factfiles are here to help young people with a broad range of issues. They're based on advice from medical professionals, age bodies, charities and other relevant groups. Follow the links for more age from these organisations. Overview Listen Later Following. Age Difference - Older. Examining the age gap www. You may also like.

Speed dating in morristown nj


Free dating sites for gay singles


Cancer survivor dating service


Internet dating websites


Dating minton pottery marks


Dating sims


Apostolic dating sites free


Alberta dating sites


How to make long distance dating work


Harmony online dating service


Dating holland


Cell phone hookup to home phone


Gratis dating norge


Best indian online dating websites


Matchmaking score


Hook up dinner


How to conduct a speed dating event


Weed hookup app


Dating advice for women over 50


Dating daan beliefs and practices


Wisconsin dating laws


Hookup apps 2016


Comments

  • User NameYozshudal

    Write to me in PM, we will talk.Research finds that one well-known guideline may not work for everyone. You are not right. I can defend the position.

  • User NameGrokinos

    Write to me in PM. In my opinion you commit an error. Let's discuss it.

  • User NameAkiramar

    Bravo, you were visited with simply brilliant idea

  • User NameYokinos

    Write to me in PM.What Is the Age of Consent? I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are not right. I am assured. Let's discuss.

  • User NameKara

    This topic is simply matchlessNavigation menu

Leave a Comment